some of my favourite songs:

Canada proposes new music tax

In the ongoing fight for the music industry to try and maintain the control they *used* to have, Canada is proposing a new compulsory music tax in addition to the digital download taxes, levy on digital music players, and the levy on blank CD’s. I kid you not, we are talking about billions of dollars collected here, and do you think I will get compensated when my music is downloaded? Nope. But Celine Dion will!

You can read the propaganda that the music industry has sent the media here.

I say propaganda because much of the information in this article comes from the music industry and is very misleading, such as the statement “More than 80% of Canada’s musicians earn less than $15,000 annually.”
This is not because of illegal downloading, but because of things like the lousy music that is released that people won’t pay for, artists who don’t promote themselves, and the fact that most artists go bankrupt because the retail stores, label, and distributors take over 70% of the profits from CD sales. Remove those people from the food chain and you have the new music industry, where the artist is back on top. and THAT is a proven fact.
(I get into this more in this post about the massive changes in the industry)
I’m really getting tired of media being too lazy to research this stuff before publishing, aren’t you?.

The incredible thing is this new tax, much like the levies mentioned above would be charged to everyone who uses the internet in Canada, not just those who download music, creating in total billions in tax and levy revenue for the music industry. How things like this get passed as law in a supposed democracy is beyond me.
What’s interesting is if it does become law, it will essentially make downloading music legal, along with burning music, which is essentially also legal now because we are paying dearly for it.
And that means that everything will change forever in the consumption of music. I only wish it could be done fairly, you know the good old way, where the industry gives the consumer what they want and get compensated for doing so, rather than by force.

4 Responses to “Canada proposes new music tax”

  1. Martin Says:


    I agree with you 100%

    The dinosaurs are unwilling to change and are holding on to old models of distribution and trying to pass shit like this to stay alive.

    Wonder why the media reports this crap?

    Guess who owns the media?


  2. jarome Says:

    It won’t help them to spread lies in this age of blogging… It’s interesting when companies are so unwilling to change, they would rather sacrifice their entire existence rather than listen to what the experts have been telling them for years!
    Kind of a sign of the times.

  3. Darrell Rodgers Says:

    So what can we Yanks down here in the USA do to awaken Canada to the folly of their ways? That government has gone tax hungry and ours will follow if it works.
    Curious note here in Tucson. I saw advertisements today for digital video recording service from my cable TV provider (“you can record a whole season of shows”). Then the news came on and announced that 14 students at the University of Arizona were being sued for downloading music. What a world.
    ///Darrell Rodgers

  4. Jarome Matthew’s Blog » the future of copyright Says:

    […] making rash decisions that hurt the most vulnerable? I talked about some of these decisions in this post that hurt content creators… Backlash against the bill was swift and strong as this article […]